I also like the last one you posted and think it will work well. I also have two rugs close by in an open floorplan. What I've found works well is to use similar colors, but to have the rugs vary either in pattern or in the predominate background color. One rug has a gold background with rust, brown and sage accents with a black border; the adjacent rug has a sage background with the rust, gold, and brown accents. They need to be different enough to stand alone, but have some elements in common in terms of style and colors to link them together.

Nice job! Before scrolling down to the bottom and without reading the posts I was going to say add some blue also. Mission accomplished!

Karen, Rug should be arriving next week. I ordered a swatch of the fabric and it's looks perfect! Problem is the Fabric.com doesnt have enough yards in stock. Fabric Guru does but I was sure if the fabric would/should look the same even though it's from different retailers. I ordered the curtains for the dining room you suggested nd they 1000x better than any other ones I've tried (thank you for that awesome pick!). I've decided to paint the dining room so that it blends better with the rest of the house. Also currently looking for a light fixture for the dining room.

When a rug works with your pillows and ottoman it usually doesn't work with your draperies which are more burgundy or wine than red. You might want to change the draperies. All of these rugs are from RugsUSA.com and range from $150 to $299. The light from your fan light is really a terrible quality. I would advise you to always use the lamps instead.This plain red rug doesn't work for the room IMO.